Why is a Swiss pillar 3a account insufficient for retirement savings? ❌

Introduction to the Swiss pension system

In Switzerland, the pension system consists of three pillars, with the third pillar being a voluntary contribution scheme. While the first and second pillars are mandatory provisions by the state and employer, respectively, the third pillar offers individuals the opportunity to save for retirement independently.

Limitations of the pillar 3a account

The maximum contribution allowed to a pillar 3a account in 2021 is CHF 6,883 for people who already contribute to an occupational pension plan. Contributions to pillar 3a are tax-deductible, which means you can deduct the full amount of the deposit from your taxable income. However, relying solely on pillars 1 and 2 may only represent around 60% of your final income during retirement, making pillar 3a seem like a logical choice. But is this really the case?

Investment options and returns

Banks and insurance companies offer pillar 3a accounts with investment opportunities that have variable interest rates and returns. For example, let's take the case of John, who opens a pillar 3a account with CHF 5,000. Depending on his risk appetite, he can choose investment products offering higher returns but with a higher risk, or opt for safer options with lower returns.

The Frankly Dilemma

Frankly, a company specializing in pillar 3a accounts, was launched in 2020. If John had invested in Frankly's Extreme 95 index from April 1, 2020, to June 30, 2021, his account balance would be $7,724 after fees. While Frankly may be one of the best options for pillar 3a accounts, it still falls short of independent investing.

‍

Take control of your retirement savings

Consider this: if John had invested his $5,000 in the stock market, specifically in the S&P 500, he would have accumulated $8,704 to date. That represents a return of 74.08% compared to the 54.48% growth of his Frankly account. Even renowned investor Warren Buffett recommends the S&P 500 to novice investors.

Considerations on fiscal responsibility

Although it could be argued that reduced tax liability is an advantage, its impact is relatively minor. The deduction amount of CHF 6,883 has a limited influence on the overall result. When comparing pillar 3a to the American retirement instrument known as a 401K, which allows workers to invest up to USD 19,500 in a tax-deductible manner, one wonders why the Swiss government has set the limit relatively low.

‍

‍

‍

Making informed choices for retirement

The reality is that not everyone feels comfortable managing their own investments. If you prefer a more passive approach, a pillar 3a account is a suitable option. However, if you feel confident taking control of your retirement savings, explore brokerage firms that can help you invest in the stock market. BitPanda is a recommended choice, offering a range of investment opportunities. Whichever path you choose, maximize your retirement strategy to secure your financial future. 💰🏦

How Earny help you with payroll and retirement planning

At Earny, we understand the importance of effective payroll management and long-term financial planning. Although we specialize in payroll services, our expertise extends to helping businesses and individuals navigate the complexities of retirement savings. With Earny, you can streamline your payroll processes, ensure accurate calculations, and comply with Swiss regulations. Our user-friendly platform also integrates seamlessly with retirement savings plans, allowing you to manage your finances efficiently. Let Earny your payroll management and help you build a solid foundation for your retirement goals. Get started with Earny today Earny take control of your financial future!